At the heart of the Tolliver Agency

Is a profound understanding that when it comes to insurance and financial services, expertise and genuine care are paramount. This agency, steered by a leader with extensive experience, is more than just a business; it’s a sanctuary for those seeking assurance and guidance in a complex world. The range of services, from home and auto insurance to retirement and commercial solutions, is delivered with a rare dedication to excellence.

What truly distinguishes the Tolliver Agency is its unwavering commitment to personal, human-centered service. The team, each a specialist in their field, doesn’t just offer services; they offer peace of mind, knowing that every recommendation is tailored to the unique needs of each client. In a world rushing towards the economical, the Tolliver Agency stands as a testament to the enduring power of quality and the human touch.

Our Story

We opened our doors in September 2020, right at the height of the pandemic. While this might seem like a crazy time to build an agency that prides itself on five star customer service, we wound up standing out in a crowd of agencies unwilling to meet their customers needs. Where other agencies were reducing staff and automating processes through chat bots, we were actively investing in new staff to serve our customers. This resonated strongly with our customers in the Mid-Atlantic region, and we quickly grew to become an Elite agency in 2023.

Mission Statement

“Our mission is to deliver an unmatched client experience in the insurance and financial services industry through innovative, personalized services and expert solutions.”

Vision Statement

“Our vision is to set the benchmark for excellence in insurance and financial planning services and to enhance the lives of our clients. We strive to not only be the best in our industry but to also make a lasting, positive impact on every individual and business we serve.”

Meet the Team

Mike Tolliver

Agency Owner

Andrea Grier

Customer Service Representative

Roy Daniels II

Account Executive

Areas We Serve

We are local to Dover, located right off Rt 1 by the Puncheon Run Connector. We have friendly staff in-office ready to help!

We also serve clients all over Delaware, providing in-person financial services to clients in Lewes, Middletown, Newark, and Wilmington.

We provide insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in the Mid-Atlantic region of Delaware, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, and West Virginia.

Finally, we provide remote financial services to clients all over the United States, using teleconferencing software to close the distance.